Italian by Night: Indulge in Authentic Italian Cuisine in Saint John

Booked a reservation for 3 to celebrate my partner's birthday. It was myself, my partner and our 8 yr old. The service was lovely, Shannon was attentive, informative and kind. It was a busy night but with the service we got, we could have been the only ones there. Really special. The food was absolutely INCREDIBLE from my kiddo's pizza to the scallops on my penne. Try the polenta if you love yourself. Can't wait to go back again for another special occasion or fancy date night!

Nice night out. Food was delicious. We had the roasted chicken and it was flavorful and very filling, but the presentation was a little messy. The osso buco was good but served cold/lukewarm. Calamari fritti app was cooked perfectly. Music from basement club was a little intrusive, so I would recommend booking earlier and being done prior to 8pm. We would go back.

If you haven’t been to this restaurant yet, what are you waiting for? From the moment we walked in, the experience was exceptional. The staff were incredibly friendly, attentive, and provided outstanding service that made us feel right at home. It was our first visit, and we couldn’t recommend it enough! Every dish was a hit—our entire group loved their meals. The Caesar salad was one of the best I’ve ever had, perfectly balanced and refreshing. The highlight for me was the spaghetti (a special not listed on the menu) recommended by our server. It came with two incredibly flavorful meatballs and tasted like it was made fresh just for us. To finish, I had the sorbet, which was light, refreshing, and bursting with fresh flavors. This restaurant is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates great food, a welcoming atmosphere, and top-notch service. We’ll definitely be back!

Excellent food from start to finish. Lively adult atmosphere. I will remember their Scoglio for years to come. Delicious. Only downside is that reservations seem to be booked back to back, so don’t be surprised if you are delayed if those before you are taking too long like we unfortunately were. Word of advice… if you don’t see availability on OpenTable, try calling in for a reservation and they may be able to squeeze you in.

We had an incredible evening at Italian by Night Trattoria as we celebrated our wedding anniversary! From the moment we arrived, everything was perfectly arranged as requested in our booking. Our server, Charlotte, was simply fantastic; she took care of all our needs with a warm smile and pleasant demeanor, making us feel special throughout the night. The hot towels before meal was also a night touch but they should add a touch of eucalyptus The meals were outstanding—each dish was a delightful experience for the palate. We couldn't resist indulging in the desserts, and they were nothing short of divine! The crème brûlée and pavlova were the perfect sweet ending to our meal. While our wine took a little longer to arrive, the exceptional service and delicious food more than made up for the delay. We left with full hearts and happy memories, thankful for such a wonderful evening. If you're looking for a place to celebrate a special occasion or just enjoy a fantastic meal, I highly recommend Italian by Night Trattoria. We can't wait to return for another unforgettable experience!

I went back to this restaurant after 6 months. First of all, they had added a partition between the two sections of the restaurant, which was great. The portion size and quality of the food had really improved, and it was absolutely delicious . I even thought maybe a new and amazing chef had joined, because in the past, both the quality and portion sizes were poor. But now, some amazing changes had taken place! A waiter named Michael served us—he was polite, exceptional, and had a friendly, warm attitude. This restaurant is now back on my list of regular places to go!

FINALLY! 5/5 across the board! We were so happy with our experience there. Food was delicious, the bustling atmosphere was never overwhelming or too loud. Instead, it was a blend of comfort and class, and our service was polite, fast, wonderful, really on all fronts. I am extremely happy with our first visit and have already decided to make it a birthday tradition! We thoroughly enjoyed the calamari appetizer. The seafood pastas were excellent, and the desert was a must. Absolutely a must visit in downtown Saint John! Get a reservation though because this is a popular spot!

Nice Italian restaurant downtown. Reservations recommended. The food was good but not perfect. Had the Ceasar salad to start: The croutons were stale, the salad dressing was good. The chicken Parmigiana itself was very good but the pasta was bland and unseasoned. Please note that it's a bechamel sauce on the chicken not tomato. The pizza is good but not $21 good. The Gin Fizz was very gin forward. The server was great and they bring you a hot towel for your hands. There was a bit of a wait for my table despite being early and having a reservation. Parking can be difficult but there's a paid parking complex nearby.